John Jaeckel: More on Leddy, Carcillo


Follow JJ on Twitter @jaeckel!


Another team involved in the Nick Leddy discussions was Florida. I also heard the Hawks might not be done dealing either—other transactions were discussed beyond those involving Leddy.

Trades are brewing all over the league and the Hawks need to lose one player off the NHL roster.


As the blogosphere ripples with varying degrees of shock and mockery over the Hawks signing Dan Carcillo, I would urge this: keep an open mind.

My only huge beef with Carcillo is his propensity for taking the odd, incredibly dumb penalty at a bad time. Let’s bear in mind, this was a problem with the guy (Brandon Bollig) Carcillo is ostensibly replacing on the roster.

Anyone saying “how about he’s a horrible hockey player,” needs to stop pining for a roster full of 168 pound, would-be top six players.

There are things Carcillo does that are not bad things to add to the Hawk roster: he finishes checks, stands up for teammates, and can actually play with more skilled linemates. It really remains to be seen if the other candidate for “the job,” Brandon Mashinter, can do all those things as well. Or if he’s just another 2 minute every other night dinosaur in the John Scott mold.


The Hawk roster currently features 8 defensemen, one belief being that one of Trevor van Riemsdyk, Kyle Cumiskey or David Rundblad has to go to Rockford. A source told me over the weekend that The former two are favorites of Joel Quenneville, and the latter of Stan Bowman. Might be a little squabble over that—and I would not rule out Mashinter going to the Rock or some other unforeseen move.


Lace ‘em up and play at BMO Center In Rockford before the November 22 Ice Hogs game to help out Have A Skate With Bob, a great charity fighting pancreatic cancer started by Hawk fan Bob Klem. Roster spots are still open in two separate games. Check it out at

All for now.


This post originally appeared on and we thank them for permission to rebroadcast it here.

Your sports. Your teams. The ISN Daily Digest.

Sign up to the ISN Daily Digest and sit back while we pick the previous day’s best headlines and speed them straight to your inbox every morning.
Email address
First Name*
We abide by all applicable emailing laws including 100% CAN-SPAM/CASL/US CAN-SPAM Act compliance. No spam!