Melky Cabrera off to White Sox

melky cabrera

 * Free-agent Melky Cabrera signed a three-year $42 million offer from the Chicago White Sox — subject to passing a physical. He’ll learn less than the $50 million deal he was looking for but more than the three-year $39 million the Jays offered before trading for Michael Saunders (Victoria, BC).


2014 Canadians in the Minors … Canadians in College
2015 Canadian draft list
2016 Canadian draft list 
Letters of Intent

Melky Goes to Chicago
By Jay Blue
Blue Jays From Away

The Melky Cabrera sweepstakes appear to be over after news broke late last night that he would be signing with the Chicago White Sox.

Interestingly, the reported deal that Melky will be signing is going to be $42 million over the course of three years which puts the contract within the range of what the Blue Jays may very well have been offering him at the beginning of the free agency period.

Cabrera will receive an $14 million annual average value of the reported contract. The original reports noted that Melky needed to pass a physical before the contract would be approved. The Blue Jays will receive a compensation pick in the draft in between the first and second rounds and will replace the 17th-overall pick that the Blue Jays forefeited when they signed Russell Martin.

What does this mean for the Blue Jays? Obviously the money and length of contract that Melky is signing for are not all that far above what the Blue Jays were probably offering. Rumours of a 3-year, $39 million contract offer were going around in November.

There was also speculation (mainly by Bob McCown on Sportsnet Radio The Fan 590) that the Blue Jays made their offer and probably asked Cabrera to come back to them to see if they would match/exceed whatever offer he had from another team. While this is all well and good, the acquisition of Michael Saunders (for J.A. Happ) probably meant that the Blue Jays weren’t going to bring Melky back, even at the reasonable, three-year contract that he appears to be getting from Chicago.

This situation brings up a series of scenarios that need a couple of conditions to be satisfied before we can proceed with the breakdown. The first condition for this hypothetical to play out is whether the three-year, $39-million offer was what the Blue Jays originally had on the table. The second is whether the Blue Jays asked Melky to have a chance to match whatever offer he got elsewhere. If those two conditions are true, then the resulting scenario of Melky going to Chicago is extremely curious.

Scenario #1: Cabrera didn’t give the Blue Jays the opportunity to match the offer. After seeing that the Jays had effectively replaced him with Michael Saunders, Melky decided to take his services elsewhere and take the money without giving the Blue Jays the opportunity to re-sign him.

Scenario #2: The Blue Jays had made up their minds to let Cabrera go after trading for Saunders. In this scenario, the money they were saving would go towards either a) players at other positions (like the bullpen or second base) or b) making up the shortfall thanks to the drop in the Canadian dollar (depending on whether you want to believe this story).

Scenario #3: The Blue Jays had made up their minds to let Cabrera go after signing Russell Martin and giving up their first-round draft pick. In this scenario, the priority then became replacing Cabrera in left field in order to make sure that they got a supplemental round draft pick in compensation.

Although this is a completely irrelevant thought experiment, each permutation of possibility really changes the way in which we should see Blue Jays’ management and their strategy for this offseason. Again, certain things that have been rumoured would have to be true for any of these scenarios to be contemplated but I find them fun to think about.

I also thought that the Blue Jays would re-sign Cabrera. I even said as much on The Cardy Show at the end of November. Yeah, that’s embarrassing. But I freely admit that I am horrible at predicting what will happen with these Blue Jays.

If you like us here,“like” us on Facebook!

Who are these players? Find out in The 2014 Toronto Blue Jays Minor League Handbook, now available as an ebook at, now at a reduced price of $2.99 US. You can purchase and preview the book at our page!

The All-Star Break Supplement to the Minor League Handbook is also available at for only $0.99 US! Get an update on how your favourite players did last season as well as a report on the 2014 draft!

Scott Harrigan
Your #1 source for community and amateur sports related news on Vancouver Island, British Columbia and beyond! Send stories to